Uterine Rupture*

During pregnancy, labor and delivery, there are typically no tears in the uterus. In certain circumstances, however, the uterus can rupture throughout some or all all its layers, compromising the fetus’ oxygen supply and jeopardizing the mother’s health.

Uterine rupture often leads to severe bleeding, and the baby may even move into the mother’s abdomen when it is time to deliver. Uterine rupture typically happen during a vaginal birth after cesarean section (VBAC) when scars from previous C-sections or uterine or abdominal surgeries tear during labor, though, in 18 percent of cases it occurs when the uterus is unscarred.

A ruptured uterus is an extremely dangerous complication that can occur during pregnancy.  If the uterus ruptures, the baby can become severely deprived of oxygen (birth asphyxia) and develop a brain injury called hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy (HIE), which can cause seizures, cerebral palsy, intellectual disabilities and developmental delays.

If a uterine rupture occurs when the baby is premature, the birth asphyxia may cause periventricular leukomalacia (PVL), which is a brain injury characterized by death and damage of the brain’s white matter, especially near the ventricles.  In PVL, fluid filled cysts may be left behind when the white matter dies.

Although more common in premature babies, PVL can occur in term babies after an insult to the brain.  Like hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy (HIE), periventricular leukomalacia can also cause seizures, cerebral palsy and developmental delays.

Medical Explanations

How a Ruptured Uterus Can Cause Birth Asphyxia

The uterus (womb) encircles the baby and the amniotic fluid.  The placenta is attached to the inside of the womb and the umbilical cord arises from the placenta.  The baby receives all her oxygen through blood that travels from the mother through vessels the run through the uterus and placenta, and then to the baby through the umbilical cord.  The path of oxygen-rich blood is as follows: uterine vessels à placental vessels à umbilical vein à baby.   Certain vessels of the uterus and placenta are part of what’s termed the uteroplacental circulation, and this circulation brings the blood to the umbilical vein.

A uterine rupture is a complete tear through all uterine layers, and it typically occurs when there is scarring from surgeries, such as a previous C-section delivery or uterine or abdominal surgeries.  A ruptured uterus creates numerous problems that can cause the baby to experience birth asphyxia.  The location and extent of the tear and the baby’s reserves play a role in how severe the birth asphyxia will be.  The baby may also end up outside the womb and in the mother’s abdomen when a rupture occurs.  Regardless of the extent of the rupture, the baby must be delivered by emergency C-section as soon as a ruptured uterus occurs in order to prevent a lack of oxygen to the baby’s brain and birth asphyxia.

A ruptured uterus can cause the baby to experience birth asphyxia by the following mechanisms:

  • The tear causes the mother to lose so much blood that she is unable to deliver adequate oxygen-rich blood to the baby.  The mother may even have such a severe hemorrhage that she goes into shock (blood pressure is severely low), which is life-threatening for the mother and baby.
  • The rupture is at or very close to the placenta and it severs vessels involved in uteroplacental circulation, thereby severely reducing the amount of blood going to the baby.
  • The rupture affects the placenta.  Placental abruption and uterine rupture can occur together.  One study found that 18% of uterine ruptures occurred when placental abruption was present and the uterus was unscarred.
  • If the baby starts to move into the mother’s abdomen when the uterus is ruptured, many serious medical complications can occur, such as the umbilical cord becoming stretched, compressed or torn.

Risk Factors for Uterine Rupture

A scarred uterus is the biggest risk factor for a ruptured uterus.  The types of scars that can cause a uterine rupture include the following:

  • Scar from a C-section
  • Hysterotomy scar.  Hysterotomy is in incision in the uterus made during a C-section when the baby has shoulder dystocia (shoulder caught on mother’s pelvis).
  • Uterine perforation scar.  This can occur as a result of any complication involving the uterus and trans-cervical procedures.
  • Myomectomy or metroplasty scar.  These scars are from the removal of fibroids in the uterus.
  • Scar from the previous repair of a ruptured uterus.

During pregnancy, imaging of scars should be performed.  An intact, thick scar means the repair of the previous C-section or any other uterine surgery was likely pretty good.  A thin scar or defect should cause the physician to worry about a possible uterine rupture during labor as well as during pregnancy.

Most uterine ruptures occur because a scar from a previous C-section is present.  Some of these involve classical C-section scars, which are longitudinal (across the abdomen), upper segment scars.  These scars can not only rupture during labor and delivery, but they can rupture during pregnancy as well.  Rupture of lower segment C-section scars usually takes place during labor.

Other risk factors for uterine rupture include the following:

  • Cephalopelvic disproportion (CPD).  This is when the mother’s pelvis is too small for the size of the baby, resulting in the baby being unable to pass through the birth canal.
  • Malpresentation.  This is when the baby is not in the normal head-first position.  Malpresentations include brow, face, breech and shoulder presentations.
  • Grand multiparity.  This is when the mother has given birth 5 or more times.
  • Uncontrolled use of Pitocin (oxytocin), Cytotec or other labor induction drugs.  This is probably the leading cause of rupture of the unscarred uterus.  Pitocin can cause contractions to be too strong and too frequent, which puts a lot of strain on the uterus.  A recent study found that in one medical center, Pitocin had been administered in 77% of their uterine rupture cases. The chance of Pitocin-induced rupture increases with women who have had previous traumatic births.
  • Placental abruption.  This is when the placental lining separates from the uterus.  This can cause the baby to be either partially or completely cut off from the mother’s circulation.
  • Multiple fetuses (twins, triplets, etc.)
  • Post-term labor
  • Operative deliveries.  Using a delivery device, such as forceps or performing internal version, can cause uterine rupture.  Internal version is when the physician inserts a hand into the womb and grasps the baby by one or both feet to turn her.

When Pitocin is used in the presence of other risk factors for uterine rupture, such as grand multiparity, malpresentation, or a previous C-section scar, it is extremely dangerous.  In fact, using Pitocin when these conditions are present is contraindicated.

Experts emphasize that the best way to prevent uterine rupture is through prophylaxis; physicians must be aware of the mother’s past medical history and must closely watch her during pregnancy and labor.  Great effort must be made in diagnosing even minor degrees of CPD or malpresentation, and in treating grand mutliparity and other risk factors, especially placental abruption.  Mothers with risk factors should be attended to and treated in a special high-risk intensive care zone in the labor department by specially trained physicians and personnel.  Difficult operative deliveries should not be attempted, and instead, delivery by C-section should take place.

A vaginal birth after C-section (VBAC) should be attempted only on a mother who has had a previous transverse, lower-uterine segment C-section for a non-recurring condition, and only after a very careful assessment has been made by the physicians with a determination that vaginal delivery would be favorable.  Informed consent from the mother is crucial, and this involves discussing all the risks of a VBAC as well as the alternatives, such as a C-section delivery.

Signs and Symptoms of Uterine Rupture

It is critical for the medical team to closely monitor a mother and baby during labor and delivery – and throughout pregnancy – so that prompt treatment of dangerous conditions such as uterine rupture can occur.

Signs and symptoms of a ruptured uterus include the following:

  • Non-reassuring heart tracings, fetal heart rate decelerations
  • Vaginal bleeding or hemorrhaging
  • Sudden abdominal pain
  • Loss of uterine contractions
  • Baby recedes back into the birth canal
  • Hemodynamic instability (blood pressure and heart rate problems)

The classic signs of uterine rupture have been shown to be unreliable and sometimes nonexistent.  Thus, non-reassuring fetal heart tones on the heart monitor are the most common and often the only signs of uterine rupture.  In most cases, signs of fetal distress will appear before pain or bleeding.  It therefore is critical that physicians pay close attention to the fetal heart monitor and be prepared to perform an emergency C-section.  When uterine rupture is present, a prompt delivery by emergency C-section delivery must occur in order to avoid birth asphyxia, hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy (HIE) and lifelong problems, such as seizures, cerebral palsy, and developmental disabilities.

Your Legal Options

Legal Help

Birth injury cases require specific, extensive knowledge of both law and medicine. In order to achieve the best results, our team believes it’s critical to specifically and exclusively handle birth injury cases. With over 100 years of joint legal experience, our legal team has the education, qualifications, results and accomplishments necessary to succeed. We’ve handled cases involving dozens of different complications, injuries and instances of medical malpractice related to obstetrics and neonatal care.

Talk to Medical Law


Medical Law:   Our Priorities
As experienced solicitors, we know how to pursue these kinds of Uterine Rupture claims.  We understand the needs of our clients.   We can employ the resources to be effective in complex medical negligence litigation.
Medical Law:  Our Promise to You
We are dedicated to the service of our clients from our initial consultation and case review until we reach a settlement or judgment on your behalf.   Your best interests are our priority.  If you or a loved one have suffered due to medical negligence, we want to help you by finding out, what happened, who was responsible and holding that responsible party or parties to account.

*In contentious business a solicitor may not calculate fees or other charges as a percentage or proportion of any award or settlement. This statement is made in compliance with Regulation 8 of S.I. 518 of 2002.

Medical Success

Your Case - Tell Us

About Us

Medicallaw.ie is a team of experienced solicitors and medical consultants who specialise in taking on medical negligence claims.

The team is headed up by Siobhan Fahy, Solicitor.

We are all well qualified in our respective fields and have years of experience in the area of medical negligence. We seek justice and financial compensation for patients who feel that they have been the victim of medical neglect.

We recognise the dedication of those who serve in our hospitals and health service, but the reality is that our health system is so inadequate that many people find they have become victims of a particular consultant or the Health Service Executive itself. We are here to help.

Our Head Office

30 Upper Pembroke Street,
Dublin 2, Ireland

+353 (0)1 442 8007

Our Cork Office

Building 1000, City Gate
Cork, Ireland

Call us Monday-Friday, 08.30-17.30 Sat, 09.30-13.00

Our Limerick Office

Ducart Suite, Castletroy Commercial Campus, Limerick

+353 (0)61 749 002